10 Best Private Internet Access (PIA) Alternatives for Speed, Privacy & Streaming in 2025

Finding the right VPN can feel overwhelming with so many options out there. I know Private Internet Access (PIA) is popular for its strong privacy features and affordable plans but sometimes it just doesn’t fit everyone’s needs. Whether you’re looking for faster speeds, a friendlier user interface or more global server locations it’s smart to explore what else is available.

I’ve spent a lot of time testing different VPNs and comparing their strengths. If you’re curious about what makes a great PIA alternative or you’re just ready for a change I’ll walk you through some top options that might suit your browsing habits and privacy demands even better.

Why Consider Private Internet Access (PIA) Alternatives

Multiple factors can drive the need to explore Private Internet Access (PIA) alternatives.

• Speed differences: I’ve noticed that some VPN providers deliver faster download and upload speeds than PIA, especially for users streaming 4K video or gaming, with examples including ExpressVPN and NordVPN.
• Server network scope: I see that alternatives frequently offer more diverse server locations, like Surfshark’s network in over 100 countries, compared to PIA’s 91.
• Feature variety: My testing shows several alternatives include unique features not found in PIA, such as double VPN, split tunneling, or SmartDNS, with CyberGhost and ProtonVPN standing out.
• User interface preference: I find that some VPNs present more streamlined, beginner-friendly interfaces, like TunnelBear’s drag-and-drop UI.
• Price and plans: Many alternatives introduce flexible plans or more competitive prices, especially during extended promotions or for family and business use.
• Bypassing geoblocks: Some services, for instance, ExpressVPN and Windscribe, consistently overcome streaming or censorship blocks that PIA sometimes can’t bypass in restrictive regions.

These differences become important when specific browsing, streaming, or security priorities aren’t fully addressed by PIA’s offering.

Key Features to Look For in VPN Alternatives

• Encryption Standards

I prioritize VPN alternatives with AES-256 encryption, like NordVPN or ExpressVPN, since this standard protects my data from unauthorized access.

• No-Log Policy

I confirm alternatives enforce strict no-log policies, as seen with CyberGhost and Mullvad, to keep my online activity confidential.

• Connection Speed

I test download and upload speeds before switching; VPNs such as Surfshark and Hotspot Shield offer reliable high-performance connections for streaming and gaming.

• Server Network Size

I consider VPNs with large server networks; Surfshark offers servers in 100+ countries, while ExpressVPN spans 105 locations, giving me more options for media access and lower latency.

• Streaming and Geoblock Bypass

I check for consistent unblocking abilities, like ExpressVPN’s proven support for Netflix and BBC iPlayer, when I want unrestricted streaming.

• Device Compatibility

I look for alternatives with apps for Windows, macOS, Android, and iOS, and support for routers—examples include NordVPN and PrivateVPN.

• User Interface

I value intuitive interfaces, such as TunnelBear’s drag-and-drop dashboard, for efficient VPN management.

• Price and Subscription Options

I compare flexible pricing and free trial periods. Services like Windscribe and ProtonVPN provide free plans, while services like CyberGhost often deliver competitive long-term rates.

• Extra Security Features

I target VPNs offering features like double VPN (NordVPN) or split tunneling (Surfshark) to enhance privacy and control over network traffic.

Top Private Internet Access (PIA) Alternatives

I’ve tested multiple VPNs that outperform Private Internet Access (PIA) for speed, streaming, and security. The following alternatives combine high-end privacy features, global server coverage, and user-focused design.

NordVPN

NordVPN delivers 5,800+ servers across 60 countries, supporting my streaming on platforms like Netflix, Hulu, and BBC iPlayer. Its proprietary NordLynx protocol optimizes speeds, reaching over 900 Mbps in speed tests (source: AV-TEST March 2024). Double VPN and Onion over VPN strengthen privacy, while apps include split tunneling and threat protection. Strict no-log policy audited by Deloitte ensures data integrity.

ExpressVPN

ExpressVPN operates 3,000+ servers in 105 locations, powering fast and stable connections for my browsing and 4K streaming. Its Lightway protocol prioritizes quick reconnections and secure performance. ExpressVPN reliably unblocks major streaming sites, with Smart DNS for device compatibility. Independent audits confirm the no-logs claims, and integrated kill switch keeps my connection private if dropped.

Surfshark

Surfshark offers 3,200+ servers in 100+ countries, providing unlimited device connections so I can secure all my gadgets. CleanWeb blocks ads and malware, while MultiHop lets me route traffic through two servers for extra anonymity. I frequently use split tunneling for flexibility across personal and work apps. Surfshark maintains competitive pricing and verified no-log policy.

CyberGhost

CyberGhost covers 11,000+ servers in 100 countries, specializing in streaming-friendly servers with pre-labeled options for Netflix, Prime Video, and BBC iPlayer. WireGuard protocol enhances speeds, with tests reaching 850+ Mbps (source: PCMag April 2024). Apps support up to 7 connections, and automatic Wi-Fi protection keeps my devices safe on public networks. Romania-based headquarters reinforce strong privacy laws.

Proton VPN

Proton VPN manages 3,200+ servers in 70+ countries, featuring a free plan with no data caps for basic usage. NetShield blocks malware and ads on all plans. Secure Core servers route my traffic through privacy-friendly countries like Switzerland and Iceland before exiting to the wider internet. All apps are open-source and independently audited. No-log policy remains central to Proton’s privacy ethos.

How to Choose the Best Private Internet Access (PIA) Alternatives for Your Needs

Identifying the ideal PIA alternative means matching key VPN functionalities to individual priorities. I focus on several evaluation points when comparing providers:

• Assessing Speed and Performance

I check provider speed test results for key locations. NordVPN, for example, frequently hits 700+ Mbps on WireGuard links in the US and UK according to Tom’s Guide. Sustained speed supports smooth 4K streaming and latency-sensitive gaming.

• Comparing Security and Privacy Features

I review details about encryption (like AES-256), security protocols, and independent audit status. VPNs with verified strict no-log policies, including ExpressVPN and Proton VPN, provide stronger data confidentiality.

• Analyzing Server Network Coverage

I compare the size and spread of server locations. Wider coverage, such as Surfshark’s 100+ country access points, helps bypass region blocks and maintain performance when traveling.

• Checking Streaming Capabilities

I test VPNs with top streaming services (ex: Netflix, BBC iPlayer, Disney+). Some, like CyberGhost, offer dedicated streaming servers for reliable content access.

• Evaluating Device Compatibility and Connection Limits

I ensure chosen alternatives support all my devices: Windows, macOS, iOS, Android, Linux, and routers. Surfshark stands out by allowing unlimited simultaneous connections where others often cap at five or ten.

• Reviewing User Interface and Ease of Use

I look for simple installs, clear dashboards, and easy settings. Services like TunnelBear use drag-and-drop elements for an intuitive experience.

• Comparing Plans and Pricing

I scan feature inclusions for each price tier. Free options, such as Proton VPN, work for basic needs, while long-term discounts from NordVPN or CyberGhost give value if premium features are required.

• Factoring in Advanced Features

I weigh bonuses like multihop, split tunneling, and built-in ad blockers. Windscribe and Surfshark bundle these extras for enhanced control.

VPN Service	Notable Speed	No-Log Policy	Server Locations	Devices Allowed	Notable Features	Price (per month)
NordVPN	700+ Mbps	Audited	60 countries	6	Double VPN, NordLynx protocol	$3.19–$12.99
ExpressVPN	600+ Mbps	Audited	105 countries	8	Lightway, TrustedServer tech	$6.67–$12.95
Surfshark	600+ Mbps	Audited	100+ countries	Unlimited	CleanWeb, MultiHop	$2.49–$12.95
CyberGhost	500+ Mbps	Audited	100 countries	7	Streaming servers, Smart Rules	$2.19–$12.99
Proton VPN	440+ Mbps	Audited	90+ countries	10 (paid)/1 (free)	Secure Core, Tor over VPN	Free–$9.99
Windscribe	400+ Mbps	Policy stated	69 countries	Unlimited	Split tunneling, custom rules	Free–$9.00

Pros and Cons of Switching to Private Internet Access (PIA) Alternatives

Switching from Private Internet Access (PIA) presents a balance of benefits and drawbacks depending on the VPN alternative I choose. I often see changes in these critical areas:

Pros

• Higher Speeds: Many PIA alternatives like ExpressVPN and NordVPN deliver faster speeds for streaming or gaming, especially on distant servers.
• Broader Server Networks: Services such as Surfshark and CyberGhost offer more server locations, improving access to international content and better connection stability.
• Advanced Privacy Features: I gain access to double VPN, obfuscated servers, and built-in ad blockers with providers like NordVPN and Surfshark.
• Improved Streaming Access: Some alternatives consistently bypass restrictive geoblocks, enabling reliable streaming on platforms such as Netflix, BBC iPlayer, and Hulu.
• User Experience: VPNs like TunnelBear and Proton VPN provide more beginner-friendly interfaces and faster setup.
• Flexible Pricing: I select free plans or long-term pricing from options like Proton VPN and Windscribe if cost is a priority.

Cons

• Potentially Higher Cost: Leading alternatives often charge higher monthly rates than PIA, with ExpressVPN and NordVPN listed among the pricier options.
• Fewer Customization Settings: Certain VPNs simplify user choices and remove some advanced settings found in PIA, reducing my control over protocol or connection tweaks.
• Learning Curve: New user interfaces or unique features sometimes require me to relearn navigation or adjust habits, especially if switching between ecosystems.
• Variable Support Quality: Customer support responsiveness and knowledge can differ, with some alternatives receiving slower or less effective user feedback.
• Inconsistent Torrenting Support: Not all alternatives match PIA’s strong torrenting performance, with providers like TunnelBear restricting P2P traffic on free or basic servers.

Changing from PIA introduces tangible differences in usability, privacy, speed, and price, making the choice of alternative critical based on my browsing, streaming, and security priorities.

Conclusion

Finding the right VPN is a personal journey and there’s no one-size-fits-all solution. I’ve tested a range of PIA alternatives and discovered that the best option really depends on your unique needs and online habits.

Whether you want faster speeds for streaming, more advanced privacy tools, or a simpler interface, there’s a VPN out there that’ll fit your requirements. Take your time to weigh the features that matter most to you and don’t hesitate to try a few options before settling on your new go-to VPN.